HOW MPs VOTED OR
DIDN’T VOTE
ON
BREITKREUZ MOTION M-83
October
1, 2003
|
|
Motion
M-83 |
|
|
That
the Standing Committee on Health fully examine, study and report to
Parliament on: (a) whether or not abortions are medically necessary for
the purpose of maintaining health, preventing disease or diagnosing or
treating an injury, illness or disability; and (b) the health risks for
women undergoing abortions compared to women carrying their babies to full
term. |
37th
Parliament
Members
of the House of Commons
October 1, 2003
NOTE: [LEFT JUST BEFORE
VOTE] indicates those MPs who voted on Motion M-387 immediately before the vote
on Motion M-83 but didn't vote at all on M-83.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Alphabetical
Listing: Bloc Québécois Party (34)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Asselin,
Gérard Charlevoix [ABSENT]
Bachand,
Claude Saint-Jean [OPPOSED]
Bergeron,
Stéphane Verchères—Les-Patriotes [OPPOSED]
Bigras,
Bernard Rosemont—Petite-Patrie [ABSENT]
Bourgeois,
Diane Terrebonne—Blainville [ABSENT]
Cardin,
Serge Sherbrooke [OPPOSED]
Crête,
Paul Kamouraska—Rivière-du-Loup—Témiscouata—Les
Basques [OPPOSED]
Dalphond-Guiral,
Madeleine Laval Centre [OPPOSED]
Desrochers,
Odina Lotbinière—L'Érable [LEFT
JUST BEFORE VOTE]
Duceppe,
Gilles Laurier—Sainte-Marie [OPPOSED]
Fournier,
Ghislain Manicouagan [ABSENT]
Gagnon,
Marcel Champlain [ABSENT]
Gagnon,
Sébastien Lac-Saint-Jean—Saguenay [ABSENT]
Gagnon,
Christiane Québec [ABSENT]
Gaudet,
Roger Berthier—Montcalm [OPPOSED]
Gauthier,
Michel Roberval [OPPOSED]
Girard-Bujold,
Jocelyne Jonquière [OPPOSED]
Guay,
Monique Laurentides [OPPOSED]
Guimond,
Michel Beauport—Montmorency—Côte-de-Beaupré—Île-d'Orléans [OPPOSED]
Laframboise,
Mario Argenteuil—Papineau—Mirabel [OPPOSED]
Lalonde,
Francine Mercier [OPPOSED]
Lanctôt,
Robert Châteauguay [OPPOSED]
Loubier,
Yvan Saint-Hyacinthe—Bagot [OPPOSED]
Marceau,
Richard Charlesbourg—Jacques-Cartier [OPPOSED]
Ménard,
Réal Hochelaga—Maisonneuve [ABSENT]
Paquette,
Pierre Joliette [OPPOSED]
Perron,
Gilles-A. Rivière-des-Mille-Îles [OPPOSED]
Picard,
Pauline Drummond [OPPOSED]
Plamondon,
Louis Bas-Richelieu—Nicolet—Bécancour [OPPOSED]
Rocheleau,
Yves Trois-Rivières [OPPOSED]
Roy,
Jean-Yves Matapédia—Matane [OPPOSED]
Sauvageau,
Benoît Repentigny [OPPOSED]
St-Hilaire,
Caroline Longueuil [OPPOSED]
Tremblay,
Suzanne Rimouski-Neigette-et-la Mitis [ABSENT]
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Alphabetical
Listing: Canadian Alliance (63)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Abbott,
Jim Kootenay—Columbia [ABSENT]
Ablonczy,
Diane Calgary—Nose Hill [SUPPORT]
Anders,
Rob Calgary West [ABSENT]
Anderson,
David Cypress Hills—Grasslands [SUPPORT]
Bailey,
Roy Souris—Moose Mountain [SUPPORT]
Benoit,
Leon Lakeland [SUPPORT]
Breitkreuz,
Garry Yorkton—Melville [SUPPORT]
Burton,
Andy Skeena [SUPPORT]
Cadman,
Chuck Surrey North [SUPPORT]
Casson,
Rick Lethbridge [SUPPORT]
Chatters,
David Athabasca [SUPPORT]
Cummins,
John Delta—South Richmond [SUPPORT]
Day,
Stockwell Okanagan—Coquihalla [SUPPORT]
Duncan,
John Vancouver Island North [SUPPORT]
Elley,
Reed Nanaimo—Cowichan [SUPPORT]
Epp,
Ken Elk Island [SUPPORT]
Fitzpatrick,
Brian Prince Albert [SUPPORT]
Forseth,
Paul New Westminster—Coquitlam—Burnaby [SUPPORT]
Gallant,
Cheryl Renfrew—Nipissing—Pembroke [SUPPORT]
Goldring,
Peter Edmonton Centre-East [SUPPORT]
Gouk,
Jim Kootenay—Boundary—Okanagan [ABSENT]
Grewal,
Gurmant Surrey Central [SUPPORT]
Grey,
Deborah Edmonton North [SUPPORT]
Hanger,
Art Calgary Northeast [SUPPORT]
Harper,
Stephen Calgary Southwest [ABSENT]
Harris,
Richard Prince George—Bulkley Valley [ABSENT]
Hill,
Grant Macleod [SUPPORT]
Hill,
Jay Prince George—Peace River [SUPPORT]
Hilstrom,
Howard Selkirk—Interlake [SUPPORT]
Hinton,
Betty Kamloops, Thompson and Highland Valleys [LEFT
JUST BEFORE VOTE]
Jaffer,
Rahim Edmonton—Strathcona [OPPOSED]
Johnston,
Dale Wetaskiwin [SUPPORT]
Kenney,
Jason Calgary Southeast [SUPPORT]
Lunn,
Gary Saanich—Gulf Islands [ABSENT]
Lunney,
James Nanaimo—Alberni [SUPPORT]
Martin,
Keith Esquimalt—Juan de Fuca [OPPOSED]
Mayfield,
Philip Cariboo—Chilcotin [SUPPORT]
McNally,
Grant Dewdney—Alouette [SUPPORT]
Meredith,
Val South Surrey—White Rock—Langley [ABSENT]
Merrifield,
Rob Yellowhead [SUPPORT]
Mills,
Bob Red Deer [SUPPORT]
Moore,
James Port Moody—Coquitlam—Port
Coquitlam [OPPOSED]
Obhrai,
Deepak Calgary East [SUPPORT]
Pallister,
Brian Portage—Lisgar [ABSENT]
Penson,
Charlie Peace River [ABSENT]
Rajotte,
James Edmonton Southwest [SUPPORT]
Reid,
Scott Lanark—Carleton [ABSENT]
Reynolds,
John West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast [ABSENT]
Ritz,
Gerry Battlefords—Lloydminster [SUPPORT]
Schmidt,
Werner Kelowna [SUPPORT]
Skelton,
Carol Saskatoon—Rosetown—Biggar [SUPPORT]
Solberg,
Monte Medicine Hat [SUPPORT]
Sorenson,
Kevin Crowfoot [SUPPORT]
Spencer,
Larry Regina—Lumsden—Lake Centre [SUPPORT]
Stinson,
Darrel Okanagan—Shuswap [SUPPORT]
Strahl,
Chuck Fraser Valley [SUPPORT]
Thompson,
Myron Wild Rose [SUPPORT]
Toews,
Vic Provencher [SUPPORT]
Vellacott,
Maurice Saskatoon—Wanuskewin [ABSENT]
White,
Randy Langley—Abbotsford [SUPPORT]
White,
Ted North Vancouver [ABSENT]
Williams,
John St. Albert [SUPPORT]
Yelich,
Lynne Blackstrap [SUPPORT]
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Alphabetical
Listing: Independent (4)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Carignan,
Jean-Guy Québec East [OPPOSED]
Lebel,
Ghislain Chambly [SUPPORT]
Pankiw,
Jim Saskatoon—Humboldt [ABSENT]
Venne,
Pierrette Saint-Bruno—Saint-Hubert [LEFT
JUST BEFORE VOTE]
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Alphabetical
Listing: Liberal Party (170)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Adams,
Peter Peterborough [ABSENT]
Alcock,
Reg Winnipeg South [OPPOSED]
Allard,
Carole-Marie Laval East [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Anderson, David Victoria [ABSENT]
Assad,
Mark Gatineau [ABSENT]
Assadourian,
Sarkis Brampton Centre [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Augustine, Jean Etobicoke—Lakeshore
[OPPOSED]
Bagnell,
Larry Yukon [OPPOSED]
Bakopanos,
Eleni Ahuntsic [OPPOSED]
Barnes,
Sue London West [OPPOSED]
Barrette,
Gilbert Témiscamingue [OPPOSED]
Beaumier,
Colleen Brampton West—Mississauga [ABSENT]
Bélair,
Réginald Timmins—James Bay [ACTING SPEAKER]
Bélanger,
Mauril Ottawa—Vanier [OPPOSED]
Bellemare,
Eugène Ottawa—Orléans [OPPOSED]
Bennett,
Carolyn St. Paul's [ABSENT]
Bertrand,
Robert Pontiac—Gatineau—Labelle [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Bevilacqua, Maurizio Vaughan—King—Aurora
[OPPOSED]
Binet,
Gérard Frontenac—Mégantic [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Blondin-Andrew, Ethel Western
Arctic [OPPOSED]
Bonin,
Raymond Nickel Belt [SUPPORT]
Bonwick,
Paul Simcoe—Grey [ABSENT]
Hon.
Boudria, Don Glengarry—Prescott—Russell [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Bradshaw, Claudette Moncton—Riverview—Dieppe
[OPPOSED]
Brown,
Bonnie Oakville [ABSENT]
Bryden,
John Ancaster—Dundas—Flamborough—Aldershot
[OPPOSED]
Bulte,
Sarmite Parkdale—High Park [ABSENT]
Hon.
Byrne, Gerry Humber—St. Barbe—Baie Verte [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Caccia, Charles Davenport [ABSENT]
Calder,
Murray Dufferin—Peel—Wellington—Grey
[OPPOSED]
Cannis,
John Scarborough Centre [LEFT
JUST BEFORE VOTE]
Hon.
Caplan, Elinor Thornhill [OPPOSED]
Carroll,
Aileen Barrie—Simcoe—Bradford [LEFT
JUST BEFORE VOTE]
Castonguay,
Jeannot Madawaska—Restigouche [OPPOSED]
Catterall,
Marlene Ottawa West—Nepean [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Cauchon, Martin Outremont [OPPOSED]
Chamberlain,
Brenda Guelph—Wellington [ABSENT]
Charbonneau,
Yvon Anjou—Rivière-des-Prairies [OPPOSED]
Right
Hon. Chrétien, Jean Saint-Maurice [ABSENT]
Hon.
Coderre, Denis Bourassa [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Collenette, David Don Valley East [ABSENT]
Comuzzi,
Joe Thunder Bay—Superior North [SUPPORT]
Hon.
Copps, Sheila Hamilton East [ABSENT]
Cotler,
Irwin Mount Royal [OPPOSED]
Cullen,
Roy Etobicoke North [OPPOSED]
Cuzner,
Rodger Bras d'Or—Cape Breton [OPPOSED]
Hon.
DeVillers, Paul Simcoe North [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Dhaliwal, Herb Vancouver South—Burnaby [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Dion, Stéphane Saint-Laurent—Cartierville [OPPOSED]
Discepola,
Nick Vaudreuil—Soulanges [OPPOSED]
Dromisky,
Stan Thunder Bay—Atikokan [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Drouin, Claude Beauce [OPPOSED]
Duplain,
Claude Portneuf [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Easter, Wayne Malpeque [OPPOSED]
Efford,
R. John Bonavista—Trinity—Conception [ABSENT]
Hon.
Eggleton, Art York Centre [OPPOSED]
Eyking,
Mark Sydney—Victoria [SUPPORT]
Farrah,
Georges Bonaventure—Gaspé—Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Pabok [OPPOSED]
Finlay,
John Oxford [ABSENT]
Folco,
Raymonde Laval West [OPPOSED]
Fontana,
Joe London North Centre [OPPOSED]
Frulla,
Liza Verdun—Saint-Henri—Saint-Paul—Pointe
Saint-Charles [ABSENT]
Hon.
Fry, Hedy Vancouver Centre [OPPOSED]
Gallaway,
Roger Sarnia—Lambton [LEFT
JUST BEFORE VOTE]
Godfrey,
John Don Valley West [ABSENT]
Hon.
Goodale, Ralph Wascana [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Graham, Bill Toronto Centre—Rosedale [ABSENT]
Grose,
Ivan Oshawa [OPPOSED]
Guarnieri,
Albina Mississauga East [ABSENT]
Harvard,
John Charleswood—St. James—Assiniboia [OPPOSED]
Harvey,
André Chicoutimi—Le Fjord [OPPOSED]
Hubbard,
Charles Miramichi [OPPOSED]
Ianno,
Tony Trinity—Spadina [ABSENT]
Jackson,
Ovid Bruce—Grey—Owen Sound [OPPOSED]
Jennings,
Marlene Notre-Dame-de-Grâce—Lachine [OPPOSED]
Jobin,
Christian Lévis-et-Chutes-de-la-Chaudière [OPPOSED]
Jordan,
Joe Leeds—Grenville [OPPOSED]
Karetak-Lindell,
Nancy Nunavut [OPPOSED]
Karygiannis,
Jim Scarborough—Agincourt [ABSENT]
Keyes,
Stan Hamilton West [OPPOSED]
Kilger,
Bob Stormont—Dundas—Charlottenburgh
[DEPUTY SPEAKER]
Hon.
Kilgour, David Edmonton Southeast [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Knutson, Gar Elgin—Middlesex—London [LEFT
JUST BEFORE VOTE]
Kraft
Sloan, Karen York North [OPPOSED]
Laliberte,
Rick Churchill River [ABSENT]
Lastewka,
Walt St. Catharines [OPPOSED]
LeBlanc,
Dominic Beauséjour—Petitcodiac [OPPOSED]
Lee,
Derek Scarborough—Rouge River [OPPOSED]
Leung,
Sophia Vancouver Kingsway [ABSENT]
Lincoln,
Clifford Lac-Saint-Louis [SUPPORT]
Longfield,
Judi Whitby—Ajax [LEFT
JUST BEFORE VOTE]
Hon.
MacAulay, Lawrence Cardigan [SUPPORT]
Macklin,
Paul Harold Northumberland [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Mahoney, Steve Mississauga West [OPPOSED]
Malhi,
Gurbax Bramalea—Gore—Malton—Springdale [OPPOSED]
Maloney,
John Erie—Lincoln [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Manley, John Ottawa South [OPPOSED]
Marcil,
Serge Beauharnois—Salaberry [ABSENT]
Hon.
Marleau, Diane Sudbury [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Martin, Paul LaSalle—Émard [ABSENT]
Matthews,
Bill Burin—St. George's [LEFT
JUST BEFORE VOTE]
Hon.
McCallum, John Markham [OPPOSED]
McCormick,
Larry Hastings—Frontenac—Lennox and Addington [ABSENT]
McGuire,
Joe Egmont [SUPPORT[
McKay,
John Scarborough East [LEFT
JUST BEFORE VOTE]
Hon.
McLellan, Anne Edmonton West [OPPOSED]
McTeague,
Dan Pickering—Ajax—Uxbridge [ABSENT]
Hon.
Milliken, Peter Kingston and the
Islands [SPEAKER]]
Mills,
Dennis Toronto—Danforth [ABSENT]
Hon.
Minna, Maria Beaches—East York [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Mitchell, Andy Parry Sound—Muskoka [OPPOSED]
Murphy,
Shawn Hillsborough [SUPPORT]
Myers,
Lynn Waterloo—Wellington [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Nault, Robert Kenora—Rainy River [OPPOSED]
Neville,
Anita Winnipeg South Centre [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Normand, Gilbert Bellechasse—Etchemins—Montmagny—L'Islet
[ABSENT]
O'Brien,
Pat London—Fanshawe [SUPPORT]
O'Brien,
Lawrence Labrador [LEFT
JUST BEFORE VOTE]
O'Reilly,
John Haliburton—Victoria—Brock [SUPPORT]
Hon.
Owen, Stephen Vancouver Quadra [ABSENT]
Pacetti,
Massimo Saint-Léonard—Saint-Michel
[OPPOSED]
Hon.
Pagtakhan, Rey Winnipeg North—St. Paul [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Paradis, Denis Brome—Missisquoi [ABSENT]
Parrish,
Carolyn Mississauga Centre [ABSENT]
Patry,
Bernard Pierrefonds—Dollard [OPPOSED]
Peric,
Janko Cambridge [SUPPORT]
Peschisolido,
Joe Richmond [ABSENT]
Hon.
Peterson, Jim Willowdale ABSENT]
Hon.
Pettigrew, Pierre Papineau—Saint-Denis
[OPPOSED]
Phinney,
Beth Hamilton Mountain [ABSENT]
Pickard,
Jerry Chatham—Kent Essex [ABSENT]
Pillitteri,
Gary Niagara Falls [OPPOSED]
Pratt,
David Nepean—Carleton [LEFT
JUST BEFORE VOTE]
Price,
David Compton—Stanstead [ABSENT]
Proulx,
Marcel Hull—Aylmer [OPPOSED]
Provenzano,
Carmen Sault Ste. Marie [OPPOSED]
Redman,
Karen Kitchener Centre [OPPOSED]
Reed,
Julian Halton [OPPOSED]
Regan,
Geoff Halifax West [ABSENT]
Hon.
Robillard, Lucienne Westmount—Ville-Marie
[OPPOSED]
Hon.
Rock, Allan Etobicoke Centre [OPPOSED]
Saada,
Jacques Brossard—La Prairie [OPPOSED]
Savoy,
Andy Tobique—Mactaquac [LEFT
JUST BEFORE VOTE]
Scherrer,
Hélène Louis-Hébert [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Scott, Andy Fredericton [OPPOSED]
Serré,
Benoît Timiskaming—Cochrane [ABSENT]
Sgro,
Judy York West [OPPOSED]
Shepherd,
Alex Durham [OPPOSED]
Simard,
Raymond Saint Boniface [OPPOSED]
Speller,
Bob Haldimand—Norfolk—Brant [ABSENT]
St-Jacques,
Diane Shefford [OPPOSED]
St-Julien,
Guy Abitibi—Baie-James—Nunavik [ABSENT]
St.
Denis, Brent Algoma—Manitoulin [OPPOSED]
Steckle,
Paul Huron—Bruce [SUPPORT]
Hon.
Stewart, Jane Brant [OPPOSED]
Szabo,
Paul Mississauga South [SUPPORT]
Telegdi,
Andrew Kitchener—Waterloo [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Thibault, Robert West Nova [OPPOSED]
Thibeault,
Yolande Saint-Lambert [OPPOSED]
Tirabassi,
Tony Niagara Centre [ABSENT]
Tonks,
Alan York South—Weston [OPPOSED]
Torsney,
Paddy Burlington [ABSENT]
Ur,
Rose-Marie Lambton—Kent—Middlesex [SUPPORT]
Valeri,
Tony Stoney Creek [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Vanclief, Lyle Prince Edward—Hastings [ABSENT]
Volpe,
Joseph Eglinton—Lawrence [ABSENT]
Wappel,
Tom Scarborough Southwest [SUPPORT]
Hon.
Whelan, Susan Essex [OPPOSED]
Wilfert,
Bryon Oak Ridges [ABSENT]
Wood,
Bob Nipissing [SUPPORT]
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Alphabetical
Listing: New Democratic Party (14)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Blaikie,
Bill Winnipeg—Transcona [ABSENT]
Comartin,
Joe Windsor—St. Clair [ABSENT]
Davies,
Libby Vancouver East [OPPOSED]
Desjarlais,
Bev Churchill [LEFT
JUST BEFORE VOTE]
Godin,
Yvon Acadie—Bathurst [OPPOSED]
Lill,
Wendy Dartmouth [OPPOSED]
Martin,
Pat Winnipeg Centre [OPPOSED]
Masse,
Brian Windsor West [ABSENT]
McDonough,
Alexa Halifax [OPPOSED]
Hon.
Nystrom, Lorne Regina—Qu'Appelle [OPPOSED]
Proctor,
Dick Palliser [OPPOSED]
Robinson,
Svend Burnaby—Douglas [ABSENT]
Stoffer,
Peter Sackville—Musquodoboit Valley—Eastern Shore [OPPOSED]
Wasylycia-Leis,
Judy Winnipeg North Centre [OPPOSED]
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Alphabetical
Listing: Progressive Conservative Party (15)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bachand,
André Richmond—Arthabaska ABSENT]
Barnes,
Rex Gander—Grand Falls [SUPPORT]
Borotsik,
Rick Brandon—Souris [ABSENT]
Brison,
Scott Kings—Hants [OPPOSED]
Casey,
Bill Cumberland—Colchester [OPPOSED]
Right
Hon. Clark, Joe Calgary Centre [OPPOSED]
Doyle,
Norman St. John's East [SUPPORT]
Hearn,
Loyola St. John's West [SUPPORT]
Herron,
John Fundy—Royal [OPPOSED]
Keddy,
Gerald South Shore [OPPOSED]
MacKay,
Peter Pictou—Antigonish—Guysborough [ABSENT]
Mark,
Inky Dauphin—Swan River [OPPOSED]
Schellenberger,
Gary Perth—Middlesex [ABSENT]
Thompson,
Greg New Brunswick Southwest [ABSENT]
Wayne,
Elsie Saint John [SUPPORT]
M-83
Voting Results from Hansard Pages 8068-8069
– October 1, 2003
http://www.cssa-cila.org/garryb/publications/Article179.htm